Making a Mushroom Garden: Learning to Design a Glorified Forest Garden

Posted by Rochelle
December 11, 2014 | Permaculture, Regional Gardens, Woodland

After ten years of staring down a large pile of hardwood logs left for me after the installation of a new home septic system, I’ve resolved to make something of this eyesore.

I’m a classically trained garden designer (that is to say, I studied in England and among many more useful things, I learned from the best about how to design 20-foot deep herbaceous borders and other stuff most normal people don’t really want). Running contrary to my formal training, notions of hügelkultur* and permaculture have recently fascinated me as I try to make manageable my own three-acre garden. The two approaches to gardenmaking couldn’t be more diff erent and I find my biggest struggle in marrying the mindsets, is resolving the part about aesthetics. One is all about making things pretty in the most planned, pruned and primped of ways, and the other relies on seeing beauty in something that most would call a weedy, messy, chaos. So as I make plans for my pile of rotting logs, I’ve set a goal of experimenting with
mushrooms and perennial vegetables (creating a gourmand’s delight), trying out plants and methods that should do the hard work for me and the ecosystem, and (here is the tricky part) figuring a way to make it look like something I would proudly share as an attractive example of garden design.
Can it be done?
Let the experiments begin.

Mushroom garden plan
If gardening is about wrestling around with Mother Nature to sculpt something of self-perceived beauty while absorbing her sometimes gut-busting blows with grace and patience, then it seems to me that beautiful mushroom cultivation might be like entering an ultimate fighting championship. Not surprisingly I have had to deal with a couple of sucker punches to my initial plans. First, my old pile of logs isn’t actually the mushroom growing haven I thought it would be and second, mushrooms don’t grow where you plant them (so much for my ideas about color coordinating companion plants). It turns out my old logs are pretty useless to most mycelium because, in general, mushrooms want fresher, more nutrient rich wood. But, I am undeterred, and have instead decided that the existing logs will largely form the base of the hügelkultur*.

We have plenty of newly fallen trees— the other half of the property is woodlands—as well as aconstant supply of garden clippings which we will impregnate with mushroom spores. So the evolved strategy is to bury the bottom half (at least) of the logs with soil, creating a base growing medium for other foodie treats like ramps, ferns (for fiddleheads), Solomon’s seal (harvest young shoots in early spring, prepare and eat like asparagus), elderberries (I can’t wait to make homebrewed cordial), sorrel and wild strawberries. We will fill the top with pockets of saw dust, coffee grounds, compost and other growing medium that will please a variety of mushrooms.

As I prepare to implement, I am faced with the third harsh reality of my experiment. This  will take time. Not only will the mushrooms potentially run and grow not where I spread or inoculated with spore, but where I least expect, and it might take months, even years, before they bloom with the fruit I seek. The rest of the time I must trust that they are growing and spreading via vast underground mycelial networks—invisible to my naked eye. The general faith of a gardener is legendary, but this is pushing even my limits.

* Hügelkultur is a composting process employing raised planting beds constructed on top of decaying wood debris and other compostable biomass plant materials. The process helps to improve soil fertility, water retention and soil warming, thus benefiting plants grown on or near such mounds. (Wikipedia)

Choosing Perennials

Making a mushroom garden Allium tricoccum - Ramps, wild leeks

Allium tricoccum – Ramps, wild leeks – Start with seeds, and a colony will gradually form over a few years but less patient gardeners can also find bulbs (in season) to get a jump on production.

Making a Mushroom Garden:  Fragaria viginiana or vesca - Wild strawberriesFragaria viginiana or vesca – Wild strawberries – Due to their short lifespan after picking, these are rare in markets. But wild strawberries are more flavorful than commercially cultivated varieties, so the best place to get them is from your own garden.

Making a mushroom garden: Polygonatum ssp – Solomon’s seal

Polygonatum ssp – Solomon’s seal – Varieties can range in height from 8 inches to 4 feet. Grown largely for its beautiful arching stems, textural leaves and herbal qualities; leaf coloring can range from silver to green and also includes variegated varieties.


making a mushroom garden - fiddlehead fernsAthyrium filix-femina (Lady fern), Osmunda regalis (Royal fern), Polystichum munitum (Western sword fern) and Osmunda cinnamomea (Cinnamon fern) are all sources for tasty fiddleheads in the spring, and each will provide lush foliage in the summer and fall.

Making a mushroom garden: Rumex acetosa - Garden sorrel Rumex acetosa – Garden sorrel – The leaves of perennial sorrel are refreshingly lemony and are often added to soups and salads. The juice of the plant removes stains from linen and natural fi bers (bonus!).


Making a mushroom garden: Sambucus nigra ‘Black Lace’ Sambucus nigra ‘Black Lace’ – Not only a source of harvestable flowers, the ‘Black Lace’ variety will also give some depth and color with its dark purple leaves.


making a mushroom garden - Lentinula edodes - Shiitake

Lentinula edodes – Shiitake prefer the dead or dying wood of broadleaf trees, and it is best to use logs that haven’t made ground contact as native soil microbes can compete with shiitake mycelium. Alternatively, shiitake mycelium can be grown on bags filled with fresh sawdust.

making a mushroom garden - Pleurotus ostreatus - Oyster mushrooms

Pleurotus ostreatus – Oyster mushrooms are the most common edible mushroom found on hardwoods. Grow on logs and stumps of alder, cottonwood, poplar, oak, birch, beech and aspen among others. After incubating, the logs may be partially buried horizontally to conserve water during fruiting. Spent oyster kits (which are a mass of sticky white mycelium typi-cally grown in straw or wheat) can also be added to a mushroom garden to inoculate a compost heap or stuff it into cracks between pieces of wood (adding sawdust, coffee grounds, and straw to help feed and maintain moisture).

Morchella angusticeps - Black morels

Morchella angusticeps – Black morels are common mushrooms to hunt for because they can be a bit tricky to cultivate. Grain spawn—a sterile culture grown on grains—can be grown on leached cow manure or morels are often grown in burn areas and will colonize ground that has been charred.

makign a mushroom garden: Stropharia rugoso-annulata - Wine cap mushrooms

Stropharia rugoso-annulata – Wine cap mushrooms, which are native to New England, can be massive (up to 5
pounds) and are typically found growing on old compost heaps in a shady area. Truly magical, they often look like rocks, are cold and firm to the touch, and they can grow fast, reaching full maturity and size sometimes between dawn and dusk. Inoculate newly disturbed soils rich in wood debris by making a moth patch—a lens-shaped patch of woodchips.

making a mushroom garden : Agaricus bisporus - Grow Portobello mushrooms

Agaricus bisporus – Grow Portobello mushrooms in mounds of inoculated leached cow manure or compost. Use cover crops to promote growth. Portobellos like to grow with other plants. Pair with kale, zucchini, squash, potatoes, melons, or similar leafy green vegetables.

making a mushroom garden: Hericium erinaceus - Lions mane mushroomsHericium erinaceus – Lions mane mushrooms taste like shrimp or lobster when cooked. These mushrooms are pure white until aged, when they begin to turn brown at the top—the perfect time to harvest. They prefer the wood of dying or dead oak, beech, or maple trees. To cultivate, use 4-foot inoculated logs buried in the ground.

Photo credits

Ramps – Charles Kinsley (CC by-SA 2.0), Strawberries – Alexander Vasin (CC by 2.0), Polygonatum – Blueridgekitties (CC by-NC-SA 2.0), Fern – Alison Nihart (CC by-SA 2.0), Rumex Acetosa courtesy of Edible Landscaping, Sambucus nigra ‘Black Lace’ – Courtesy of Proven Winners

Mushrooms: All images via with the exception of Wine caps – Ann F. Berger (CC by SA-3.0), Portobello – Ron Pastorino – (CC by SA-3.0)

Other Posts You Might Like...

Posted by rochellegreayergmail-com | November 10, 2014
Gardens are inextricably linked to the people who tend them. It is a deep relationship, where one depends on the other. In every issue, we will take a tour of a garden with its creator...
Posted by rodney-eason | May 28, 2014
It is late May here in Maine and we are in the midst of a long, cool spring. The temperatures have only risen above 70 degrees a couple of times...
tennis court handrails at chanticleer garden via
Posted by rodney-eason | March 19, 2013
In case you missed the other posts (here and here), each week I am writing about one of my favorite gardens for their use of design and plants. In this...